FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $189 USE CODE: FREESHIP189

HALLOWEEN DAY SALE - Use Code HALLODAY For %5 OFF On All Orders Over $99
Icon Logo
Icon Close

Delve Into What Makes Bourbon And Rye Different

Delve Into What Makes Bourbon And Rye Different

Delve Into What Makes Bourbon And Rye Different

Have you ever wanted to explore beyond your usual bar? Want to know about a spirit steeped in American tradition? If your answer is yes, then you are at the right place because we are about to explore the Wild West of whiskey—Bourbon and Rye! 

These two titans of American spirits are like distant cousins sharing a rich history and a deep love for charred oak barrels. But you need to be aware! Don’t be fooled by their similarity. Bourbons like Basil Hayden Bourbon Whiskey, Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey, Yellowstone Bourbon Whiskey has a smooth, sweet charm with notes of vanilla and caramel. On the other hand, Rye like Templeton Rye, Angels Envy Rye, Pikesville Rye has a bold character with a touch of a spice cabinet and a peppery kick that will leave your taste buds tingling.
So, buckle up, partner! Here at Royal Batch, we will discuss Bourbon and Rye, their distinct personalities, flavor profiles, and the perfect way to enjoy them. This is the showdown you won’t want to miss!

Bourbon Vs. Rye
Bourbon and Rye hold a special place in the hearts and, of course, in the glasses of whiskey enthusiasts. However, both spirits cater to people with different flavor profiles and personalities. Choosing between them can feel like picking a favorite gunslinger in a western showdown—isn’t it? But you don’t have to worry because we are here to brief you about these two American whiskey giants.

The Smooth Charm of Bourbon
Bourbon is renowned for its pleasant and velvety flavor.  Bourbon is made from at least 51% maize and matured in freshly charred oak barrels. This gives it a flavor profile that frequently hints of caramel, vanilla, and toasted oak.  Its origins are traced back hundreds of years to the American South when early immigrants used readily available corn to adapt European whiskey-making processes.  Rules are essential to establishing and guaranteeing the quality and authenticity of Bourbon.  These rules specify that only recently harvested charred oak barrels may be used for aging, which greatly enhances the distinctive flavor of Bourbon.

The Spicy Kick of Rye
Conversely, rye whisky has a strong and assertive spirit. Its signature burst of pepper and spice comes from a mash bill that includes at least 51% rye grain.  The actual percentage of Rye can change, affecting the spice is strength.  Due to its distinct flavor profile, rye whisky has seen a comeback in recent years, drawing in a new generation of drinkers.  Enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or mixed into a traditional cocktail, Rye provides a distinctive and lively taste.                

Breaking Down the Bourbon Top Contenders
Are you ready to meet some of the leading players in the bourbon arena- Basil Hayden Bourbon Whiskey, Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey, Yellowstone Bourbon Whiskey?

1. Basil Hayden's Bourbon Whiskey
This smooth and approachable Bourbon is an excellent starting point for those unfamiliar with the style.  Its flavor profile is dominated by flavors of vanilla and honey, resulting from its high maize content and slight rye grain impact.

Notes on Tasting:
  • Aroma: Mint, lemon, and honey notes.
  • Taste: Light and smooth with hints of honey, baking spice, and vanilla.
  • Finish: Crisp and brief, with a hint of residual sweetness.
  • Color: Light amber 
Price range: $52.99

Proof (ABV): 80 proof (40% ABV) 

2. Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey
Its silky character is not to be taken lightly! Breckenridge Bourbon's increased rye mash bill gives it a slightly fierier rye punch.  It has a hint of regional flair and can be supplied from either Colorado or Kentucky, depending on the particular kind.

Notes on Tasting:
  • Aroma: Caramel, vanilla, with a trace of rye spice.
  • Taste: Mellow and well-balanced, with hints of caramel, baking spice, vanilla, and peppery Rye.
  • Finish: Medium-length with rye spice's lingering warmth.
  • Color: Rich amber 
Prices Range: $45.99

Proof (ABV): 86 instances (43% ABV)

3. Yellowstone Select Bourbon Whiskey
Bourbon has won multiple awards and is renowned for its balance and sweetness.  Each sip is rewarded with a warm and inviting finish and an explosion of rich vanilla and caramel flavors. Yellowstone select bourbon whiskey demonstrates the adaptability of Bourbon, which appeals to both experienced drinkers and curious beginners.

Tasting Notes:
  • Aroma: A bit of spice, caramel, oak, and vanilla.
  • Taste: Rich and velvety, with overpowering aromas of caramel, baking spices, and vanilla.
  • Finish: Warming and long-lasting, with a hint of sweetness.
  • Color: Depending on the age statement, use deep amber or reddish-brown.
Prices Range: $212.99 

Proof (ABV): 50.5% ABV (101 proof)

Top Rye Whiskey Contenders
After exploring the velvety charm of Bourbon, let's move on to the robust and piquant realm of Rye whisky. These are a few of the top options, each putting its special spin on the rye experience:

1. Templeton Rye Whiskey
This brand has a hint of mystery. Templeton Rye whisky has gained recognition for being remarkably smooth and accessible, even though it is made with the lowest amount of Rye required by law. Its pleasant flavor makes it an excellent option for those trying rye whisky for the first time.

Tasting Notes:
  • Aroma: Citrus peel, rye spice, and a dash of vanilla.
  • Taste: Notes of vanilla, baking spices, and rye spice are present but balanced.
  • Finish: Medium-length, with a hint of sweetness and a lingering warmth.
  • Color: Light to medium amber.
Prices Range: $39.99

Proof (ABV): 86 instances (43% ABV)

2. Angel's Envy Rye Whisky
This avant-garde Rye elevates the category to new heights with its distinct finishing technique. Angel's Envy Rye is aged a second time, first in ruby port wine barrels, following an initial aging period in freshly charred oak barrels. This is a nuanced and engaging experience as the rye spice combines with fruity and nutty notes to create a beautiful marriage of flavors.

Tasting Notes:
  • Aroma: A hint of red fruit, cocoa, vanilla, and rye spice.
  • Taste: Notes of red fruit, chocolate, rye spice, and a hint of vanilla sweetness combine to create a rich and nuanced flavor.
  • Finish: Medium-length, with a hint of fruit, spice, and lingering warmth.
  • Color: Rich amber with hints of red.
Prices Range: $64.99

Proof (ABV): 86 instances (43% ABV)

3. Pikesville Rye Whisky:
With a rich past, Pikesville Rye has been a family favorite for many years. Pikesville Rye, recently brought back to life by Heaven Hill Distillery, has a deep and nuanced flavor profile. A symphony of flavors showcasing the depth and promise of Rye whisky may be expected, with notes of cocoa, baking spice, and a hint of rye pepper.

Tasting Notes:
  • Aroma: Hints of citrus, chocolate, baking spices, and rye spice.
  • Taste: Complex and rich, with hints of citrus, chocolate, baking spices, and rye spice.
  • Finish: Warming, long-lasting spice with a hint of oak.
  • Color: Reddish-brown to deep amber.
Prices Range: $49.99

Proof (ABV): 86 instances (43% ABV)

Which Is Your Champion: Rye or Bourbon?
We have delved into the realms of American whisky titans, Rye, and Bourbon. The crucial query is which one tastes the best, in your opinion.

There really isn't just one "better" option. Everything comes down to individual taste.

Do you yearn for an approachable, smooth spirit with caramel and vanilla flavors? Bourbon might be the ideal choice for you.

Are you seeking something spicier with a kick of spicy Rye? Your new best friend may be rye whisky.

Exploration is where the beauty is found! Try them both and see which (or both!) suits your palette best. Don't be scared to try both.

A little advice: Rye and Bourbon pair well with traditional cocktails.  Try an Old Fashioned or a Mint Julep for Bourbon. If you're going with Rye, think about a Manhattan or a Sazerac.

Remember that the world of whisky is enormous and fascinating.  As long as you follow Royal Batch as your guide, you'll soon become an expert on whisky!  Now, friends, raise a glass and let the discovery begin!

Go Back

Selected Brands

I am over the age of 21 and agree to the terms of use for this site.